In “Derailed”, in our [November/December issue, on sale now], Hûw Steer returns to his Great Martian Railway. In this post, he dives into that decision, and some of the choices he made.
by Hûw Steer
Nuclear-powered steam trains on Mars. I do adore writing science-fiction.
Back in Analog’s July/August 2024 issue, I wrote “Great Martian Railways”, a tale of old-fashioned engineering brought into the future: the trial of a new long-range transport system between the fledgling colonies of the Red Planet, in the form of the aforementioned nuclear steam trains. Why steam? Because it’s just better, that’s why. How does it work? Check out my previous contribution to the Astounding Analog Companion for a full breakdown, but to summarize: if a nuclear reactor is essentially a big steam engine, why not just put it on wheels and rails?
But the thing about “Great Martian Railways” is that, on the whole, things go pretty well. This is a Mars with established cities, with thousands of inhabitants and all manner of infrastructure. This is a Mars where a lot of the major teething problems of an un-terraformed colony (deadly temperatures, deadly radiation, deadly not having any oxygen) have been if not solved then at least ameliorated. Thus, this is a Mars where building a 200-tonne nuclear steam engine is both possible and plausible. The first run along the rails between Elysium City and Hellas Crater is not without problems, but it is successful. The Great Martain Railway is allowed to keep building its network. Everything is fine.
So of course I had to write another story about what happens when everything is not. This whole story was, in many ways, an excuse for me to look at the world I set up in “Great Martian Railways” and then figure out how to break it. Let’s look at how I did that.
Fault On The Line
Mars is not an especially hospitable environment. It is, largely, an endless desert of ruddy sand and rock, without air, water, or shelter. When one is tucked up safely in a dome city, or thundering between said cities in a sealed metal tube, this is not a problem. Even if you’re in a space suit then you’re at least fine for a while—but not for long. And when building a railway network many thousands of kilometers long, then more often than not a GMR engineer is going to find themselves a very long way from home. Which again is not a problem, normally, because a nuclear engine like the Rocket can travel at five hundred kilometers per hour, for hours, and barely break a sweat. A rockfall across the track, a break in the line—these are not issues that would perturb an intrepid train-driver for long, because they could simply turn around and head back. As long as there are rails, there are no problems.
So of course I had to throw my steam train off the rails. Now it’s a problem.
Because it’s an enormous nuclear steam train, weighing many, many tonnes even in Mars’ weak gravity, and thus quite difficult to drag back up onto the rails again…especially when Chief Lowell, protagonist of both GMR stories, is on her own. Off the rails means no movement, anywhere, without some seriously clever thinking. But how could such an accident even occur? Mars may be a barren landscape but it is a barren landscape; there are no sheep that could wander onto the tracks, no leaves on the line. There is dust, of course, but if you’ve read “Great Martian Railways” you’ll know that Lowell has already encountered and solved that problem with careful application of static electricity. Some big rocks could do it, but the Rocket is, again, a multi-hundred tonne monstrosity easily capable of pushing rocks out of the way.
So I dug a big hole instead. Whoops: looks like that section of ground isn’t nice solid regolith but a sinkhole full of dust instead, and while a set of rails aren’t heavy enough to collapse it, a whole steam train is more than enough. A nice big break in the rails, entirely impassable. I wasn’t so cruel as to drop the train into the hole, because that really would have been impossible to get out of, but it’s still nasty enough a problem. And a problem that any prospective rail-builders across Mars will have to deal with: if you’re using heavy machinery then you need to make sure the ground is up to it, red rock or no. Radar or some other form of futuristic density measurement will be a must. We know what sort of strain the Earth can take, because we’re walking around on it (and even then we still build houses that fall down slightly…like mine…)—but so far we’ve only sent tiny little rovers out to Mars. Exploration is one thing, infrastructure is another.
We Apologize For The Delay
The problem is setup: big hole, no track, fallen train. But any sensible engineer would plan for eventualities like this. Mars is a hostile place, and those hostile aspects are known and, given there are people living on it in these stories, at least partially solved. How, then, do I counter each of my own emergency measures in turn?
Why can’t Lowell just radio for help? Well, when there are machines that can eat up thousands of kilometers of railway in a few hours, help can, in theory, arrive swiftly. But can it get there swiftly enough? Even at maximum speed, a rescue engine will take hours to arrive, and Lowell is the fastest driver on the railway. Not much good when she’s the one who’s stuck. But still, slow help is better than nothing, right? Not if I break the train’s radio antenna in the derailment . . . and not if I throw a dust storm into the mix to ruin most prospective signals.
(Now, I may be no scientist, but I have read The Martian, and I have also read the various actual scientific dissections of the book which clarify that the Martian atmosphere is so thin that dust storms don’t actually do much. There are no massive waves of sand blocking out all light or knocking over hapless astronauts; there’s just not enough air pressure for that. However, like Andy Weir, I choose to go with the more interesting and dangerous fiction over reality in this case…because it’s a really exciting image, isn’t it?)
This whole story was, in many ways, an excuse for me to look at the world I set up in “Great Martian Railways” and then figure out how to break it.
So Lowell is stuck far from home with no radio and a storm in the air. “No problem,” I hear you say, “surely there’s plenty of oxygen stored aboard such a big machine, for long trips or in case of emergency.” Not if I punch a hole in the side of the engine there isn’t! With the bonus of damaging the actual nuclear reactor, reducing the amount of water in the boiler, and making that on the verge of overheating and exploding, this brings home the main problem of being on Mars, which is that your resources are limited and everything wants to kill you.
Why not carry extra water for the reactor, or some sort of other coolant; why not load up on air and food, an emergency rover, even, and the kitchen sink into the bargain? Because this wasn’t meant to be a survival scenario, it was meant to be a shipping scenario, and when you’re pulling heavy freight you need to be careful about how much weight you’re lugging. Every carriage full of supplies is one fewer carriage full of valuable cargo, and the Great Martian Railway is a business as well as an engineering marvel. Capitalism strikes again.
(Also, messing about with the internals of a broken nuclear reactor in the middle of the desert is probably not an activity associated with long-term health.)
Throw in some light injuries for good measure, and we have a proper ticking clock. Either Lowell fixes the train, or she dies.
Planned Engineering Works
One of the things I find most fun about writing sci-fi and fantasy is having to make up unconventional solutions to what should be simple problems. Humans have known how to fix heavy machinery since they invented heavy machinery, and given much of that heavy machinery was in fact trains and train-related accessories, mending a fallen locomotive should be child’s play. Well, child’s play if said child also has access to some heavy machinery.
There’s a big hole in your Space Train. What do you do? Weld it shut, obviously. Except that a welding torch needs to burn, which requires oxygen, and Mars hasn’t got any. (There are, apparently, laser welders, which is awesome, but they still get things extremely hot, and that sort of thing is generally frowned upon in the context of “limited oxygen reserves” and “pointing a laser at a nuclear reactor”.) So I had to get creative with the Rocket’s onboard patch kit, because of course no self-respecting Martian engineer would leave home without one. Now I may use fancy words like “carbon composite”, but what Lowell has here is essentially a big space sticking-plaster, heated up and applied with a space hairdryer. Whatever works. And I think it would, at least temporarily.
A small and simple fix I was particularly proud of was Lowell’s injured leg. It’s hard to apply a plaster cast in the cab of a locomotive in the Martian desert, but if you’re already wearing a pressure suit, with joint reinforcements and thick cloth and all that jazz, why not leave the possibility of more reinforcement? All you would need is some screw-threads and a metal rod, and you’ve got an instant leg or arm brace. A key addition to any first-aid kit of the future, I’d say.
How do you lift a two-hundred tonne lump of metal into the air? Well, thankfully, this is Mars, and gravity is more of a firm suggestion than a rule. 200 tonnes becomes about 75 tonnes, which, while still enormous, is an awful lot less enormous. A plausible weight to be hefted by some manner of mobile crane, for instance. And thankfully, there is one available-ish. Because how does one even build a railway network on airless Mars? It’s an awful lot more effort to send out a team of navvies to lay track when each one has to be in a space suit, even if everything weighs less—and when your network is going to be thousands of kilometers long then pure human effort simply isn’t enough. I needed robots. Rail-laying drones that could be sent out far into the wastes with a big load of rails and build their own routes as they went. Rapid, accurate rail-laying on a huge scale. Where have I seen that before…
Gromit. I simply could not resist. Though I will apologize to the Analog editors for not only insisting on metric measurements but also hinging a key component of the story on such a quintessentially British bit of culture. But we as humans—and certainly Lowell as a character, given how her Rocket is literally her child in her eyes—do have a tendency to anthropomorphize just about everything. If you’re going to assign anything a personality, it’s going to be a plucky little machine like this.
These drones are designed, essentially, to take big lengths of metal and nail them into the ground…in other words, to lift big things and then move them around. Could that lift tens of tonnes of locomotive? Maybe. It’s worth a shot for Lowell.
Even if you can get your train back on its tracks, even if you can somehow get back on course for home—because of course you can’t just set off across the open desert when you’re in a locomotive, which is the one flaw I will admit to in the concept of trains, will the Rocket even run fast enough to get you home?
Well, for that, you’ll have to read the story. I’ve already spoiled far too much of it here, but I got excited.
Making Tracks
There are plenty more problems waiting for the Great Martian Railway. Mars may be dry and barren but its terrain is still wildly varied; its mountains soar impossibly high, its valleys impossibly low. How do you get a train up or down there? How do you cross those vast wounds in the regolith? What of the ice caps to the north—surely a priority for rail infrastructure, to bring water down to the burgeoning colonies? Hell, what about running passenger services, when there’s clearly enough danger just in a single person driving out across the Red Planet? How do you build an efficient train station when there’s no air to breathe? The queues for the airlock alone would surely be a nightmare.
I’ve been thinking about all of these. I may even have been writing about them. If nothing else, the idea of a steam railway on Mars is an exciting challenge. It’s the sort of thing real engineers and scientists could spend decades working on, if humanity ever actually gets there and starts putting down roots.
I am but a lowly writer. But I’ll have a go anyway.